← Back to results
The Round Up
La Rafle
2010 115 min France, Germany, Hungary 16+
★6.6
Drama, History, War
Director: Rose Bosch
Trailers
EN
EN
Description
A faithful retelling of the 1942 "Vel' d'Hiv Roundup" and the events surrounding it.
Budget:
$20M
Worldwide:
$25.35M
Starring
Jean Reno
Actor
Mélanie Laurent
Actor
Gad Elmaleh
Actor
Awards
1 win total
Key opinion
La Rafle is a historical drama that divides critics and audiences regarding its artistic execution, though there is a shared recognition of the importance of its subject matter. While some praise its realistic portrayal of the 1942 Vel' d'Hiv roundup and strong cast, others criticize the film for relying on melodramatic tropes and lacking technical innovation.
| Culture | The film succeeds in documenting the historical reality and personal tragedies of the 1942 Vel' d'Hiv roundup, serving as a necessary reminder of the Holocaust. | |
| Acting | The cast, particularly Mélanie Laurent and Gad Elmaleh, provide credible and grounded performances that anchor the narrative. | |
| Emotion | The film is heavily criticized for its reliance on manipulative, sentimental tropes regarding children to force an emotional reaction. | |
| Cinematography | Opinions on the cinematography are divided; some find the production design and period-accurate sets immersive, while others condemn the visual style as minimal and uninspired. | |
| Screenplay | Critics are split on the screenplay's quality: some praise its focus on French collaboration and the human experience, while others dismiss the script as predictable, historically inconsistent, and lacking originality compared to genre classics. |