← Back to results
Nobody But Us...
Никто, кроме нас...
2008 110 min Russia 16+
★6.7
War, Drama, Romance
Director: Sergei Govorukhin
Trailers
EN
EN
EN
Description
Фильм снят по повести Сергея Говорухина "Никто, кроме нас". Эта картина не столько о самой войне, сколько о взаимоотношениях кинооператора Евгения Левашова и Наташи - женщины, которую он искал всю жизнь, и нашел за несколько недель до своей очередной командировки на войну. И хотя он может отказаться от этой поездки, он этого не делает - потому что любовь и нравственный выбор неразрывно связаны между собой…
Starring
Sergey Shnyryov
Actor
Mariya Mironova
Actor
Sergey Makhovikov
Actor
Key opinion
This war-drama functions as a sincere, deeply personal exploration of the trauma and internal conflicts of a veteran-turned-director. While some audiences resonate with its emotional honesty and poetic depiction of love amidst conflict, others criticize it for being overly simplistic, cliché-ridden, and lacking cinematic nuance.
| Emotion | The film succeeds in conveying a genuine, heartfelt perspective on war and loss, rooted in the director’s personal background. | |
| Pacing | The narrative structure effectively balances the harshness of war with intimate, peaceful moments of love. | |
| Acting | Performances, particularly by Maria Mikorova, provide a grounding presence in an otherwise inconsistent production. | |
| Screenplay | The script draws criticism for relying on heavy-handed symbolism, pompous dialogue, and a lack of subtlety. | |
| Originality | Opinions on the film's artistic merit are deeply divided; some see it as a purposeful, sincere debut, while others find the storytelling amateurish and filled with clichés. |