← Back to results
The Craigslist Killer
2011 95 min United States of America 18+
★5.8
Drama, Thriller
Director: Stephen Kay
Trailers
Description
Based on a true story, seemingly flawless Philip Markoff, a charismatic and popular medical student at Boston University, leads a double life and starts to descend into a twisted world of gambling, crime, battery, and eventually murder, all while meeting his victims via Craigslist.
Starring
Jake McDorman
Actor
Agnes Bruckner
Actor
Joshua Close
Actor
Key opinion
The Craigslist Killer is widely regarded as a mediocre true-crime production that struggles with its tonal focus and narrative execution. While it draws some interest for its premise and specific performances, it generally fails to deliver the suspense or depth expected of the thriller genre.
| Screenplay | The film fails to generate effective suspense, prioritizing romantic elements over the tension required for a compelling thriller. | |
| Theme | The narrative suffers from shallow character development, preventing the audience from connecting with the themes of hidden darkness. | |
| Ending | The resolution is underdeveloped and tonally inconsistent, leaving the climax feeling rushed and unsatisfying. | |
| Originality | The film creates a polarized experience: some viewers find the premise and lead performance engaging, while others criticize the shallow storytelling and lack of genre-specific tension. |