← Back to results
The Place Promised in Our Early Days
雲のむこう、約束の場所
2004 90 min Japan 18+
★7.1
Animation, Adventure, Drama, Romance
Director: Makoto Shinkai
Trailers
EN
EN
EN
Description
In a post-war alternative timeline, Japan is divided into the North, controlled by the Union, and the South, controlled by the United States. A mysterious high tower rises within the borders of the Union. Three high school students promise to cross the border with a self-built airplane and unravel the secret of the tower.
Worldwide:
$44,483
Starring
Hidetaka Yoshioka
Actor
Masato Hagiwara
Actor
Yuka Nanri
Actor
Awards
1 win & 1 nomination total
Key opinion
Makoto Shinkai's debut feature is widely celebrated for its breathtaking, cloud-laden visuals and evocative, melancholic atmosphere. While many viewers find its blend of sci-fi, romance, and teenage longing deeply resonant, others argue the plot is disjointed, burdened by underdeveloped scientific concepts and inconsistent pacing.
| Cinematography | Shinkai's signature animation delivers breathtaking landscapes, particularly in its masterfully rendered skies and lush, light-filled environments. | |
| Score | The film's melodic and atmospheric soundtrack serves as a powerful narrative device that effectively reinforces the emotional weight of the story. | |
| Screenplay | The narrative oscillates between poetic, character-driven longing and confusing, pseudo-scientific plot points that fail to reach a coherent resolution. | |
| Pacing | The meditative, slow-burning rhythm allows for deep emotional immersion for some, while others find the experience drags and struggles to maintain attention. | |
| Theme | The alternate-history political setting provides a striking backdrop, but it remains largely disconnected from the personal drama, leaving the conflict feeling underdeveloped. |